Thanks for visiting The Mortgage Reports. To stay absolutely current on mortgage markets and important guideline changes, be sure to take my free daily email alerts.

Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) came back in vogue in 2007 for a number of reasons, the most widely-known of which was that PMI was suddenly tax-deductible.

But it came with a catch.  Only families earning less than $100,000 could take the full tax deduction.  For everyone else, PMI was same as it ever was.

Quietly, though, a less-well-known mortgage option called "Lender-Paid Mortgage Insurance" is emerging as a popular PMI alternative.

Lender-Paid MI is winning hearts for two major reasons:

1. Tax deductions are available for all income levels, not just under $100,000
2. Lender-Paid Mortgage Insurance is less expensive than a comparable Private Mortgage Insurance program in the near-term

LPMI is nothing new; it just wasn't as popular back when private mortgage insurance was still cheap and home values were leaping year-over-year. 

But the lower monthly carrying cost doesn't mean that Lender-Paid MI is a better choice for every homeowners vis-à-vis Borrower-Paid MI. 

In fact, even though it's more expensive, there are certain cases where Borrower-Paid MI is actually preferred to Lender-Paid MI.  This is because Borrower-Paid MI eventually "ends".

With Borrower-Paid MI, a homeowner makes separate payments each month to the mortgage insurer and is required to do this until his loan-to-value dips below 80% (or whatever LTV the lender requires to remove PMI).

When the loan-to-value gets to the 80% point -- either through principal paydown, home appreciation, or both -- the mortgage insurance payment are no longer required and are eliminated.

To the homeowner, this is a true "cash savings" each month because a former monthly expense is now, well, former.

By contrast, Lender-Paid MI lasts forever.  This is because LPMI is an interest rate adjustment made at the time of closing.  A 6.000% rate becomes 6.250%, for example. 

In exchange for making larger payments, the lender agrees to "insure" the home loan themselves.

The positive part of LPMI being a part of the home loan note rate is that the IRS treats the additional mortgage interest paid from the higher rate as a tax-deductible expense; there is no technical difference between a mortgage with LPMI and one without it.

The negative part is that as the home's LTV falls to 80% or lower, the LPMI-fueled higher interest rate remains.  It doesn't fall off like BPMI. 

The only way that a homeowner can rid himself of LPMI is to remortgage into a new home loan.

In the end, electing between Lender-Paid MI and Borrower-Paid MI is not as simple as just making a payment comparison -- it requires attention to short- and long-term financial goals. 

LPMI tends to be fit short-term planning and BPMI tends to fit long-term planning but there are always exceptions.  This makes choosing between the two more difficult than just finding "the lowest payment".

---

Dan Green is an active loan officer. Email or call 513-443-2020. Dan is on Twitter at @mortgagereports.